Veronica Mars

One thing I’m doing now that we have Netflix is finally watching all of those TV shows that everyone said “You have to watch this, you’ll love it!” Including Veronica Mars.

Veronica Mars is so clearly inspired by perennial Sarah-favorite Buffy the Vampire Slayer that comparison between the two is inevitable (and very much done). The similarities in the basic outlines are … uncanny. Formerly popular but now outcast snarky/sarcastic teen girl with single parent solves cases of weird stuff that goes on in high school, both small weird stuff but also with a background of big weird stuff for each season. Add in the sarcastic quipping and it’s very clear why Netflix recommended VM to me based on my ratings of everything Joss Whedon ever wrote.

All that’s missing in Veronica Mars is the supernatural. Where Buffy dealt with teenage girl-ness in a supernaturally-influenced metaphorical sense, VM does it head-on. There’s nothing metaphorical in Veronica’s being drugged & raped before the show begins; there’s nothing metaphorical in her best friend’s murder-by-blunt-force-trauma. And yet… I think Buffy dealt with the issues in a more deep way. We never see Veronica struggle with the aftereffects of her assault; it comes up when it’s convenient but otherwise doesn’t seem to be an issue in her daily life.

Much like Buffy, Veronica Mars suffered with the transition to college. The quality of the plots (but not of the dialogue) declined with the second (VM’s senior year of high school) and third seasons. The behavior of the supporting characters got more and more inconsistent as well. Is Logan the 09er bad boy? Is he a tortured soul? Why in the very end of season 3 does Dick Casablancas suddenly become something other than a jerky playboy? Why does Keith take the moral high ground sometimes and not other times? (Though this could have been mitigated by having a better idea as to his motivations.)

On the other hand, I have a perverse love of Enrico Calontoni and you can’t argue with guest stars like Alyson Hannigan, Patty Hearst, and Laura San Giacomo as one of Keith Mars’ many love interests (I admit it… I watched Just Shoot Me and I loved their chemistry in that show, too). The arc of the first season was definitely compelling, even if the subsequent two seasons weren’t as good.

Verdict: Not as good as Buffy. Definitely watch the first season, maybe watch the second season, give season 3 a pass.

Advertisements

Leave a comment

No comments yet.

Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s